In 1868, President Johnson chose Evarts as a member of his defense team during the President’s removal trial in the Senate. The lawyer had been suggested by Secretary of State William Seward, a fellow-Republican and friend from New York. In mid-April, the President privately expressed his dissatisfaction with Evarts, whom he thought had let House prosecutor Benjamin Butler get away with character assassination. By early May, however, an emotionally rejuvenated Johnson concluded that he was “greatly pleased with Evarts’ efforts.” A talented orator, he gave a four-day summation at the trial. Following the President’s acquittal, Johnson named Evarts Attorney General, again at Seward’s suggestion, after the Senate had rejected the reappointment of Stanbery. This time, the Senate approved the President’s choice.